8 Comments
User's avatar
Stout Yeoman's avatar

Multiculturalism's veneration of minority groups and their parallel societies is diluting the core beliefs, principles, and standards that have traditionally guided behaviour and a shared idea of what is right and wrong. The Church of England may have declined in recent decades, but up until about 20 years ago its values permeated society and state still. We were tolerant to the point of tolerating the intolerant.

This valuable list of what is distinctively British needs promulgating and not least in Westminster and the main media whose inhabitants and controllers would benefit from travelling widely in the UK to see how these values are eroding or being actively undermined.

We should not apologise for who we are (or were it sometimes feels like), nor should we trumpet who we are/were jingoistically. There needs to be a quiet confidence without shyness, a daily affirmation in who we are that is visible by its inner certainty.

Duncan Heenan's avatar

I agree with most of what is said by Nigel Biggar, but I have reservations about his assertion that the presence of bishops in the House of Lords works to “ …enhance the House of Lords with Anglican bishops whose diocesan responsibilities put them in touch with Britons living in a wide range of social conditions .”

My own view is that this hoped for benefit is little realised in practice. The very selection and promotion process for Bishops seems to exclude those with the greatest experience of ordinary folk. The system of communication via sinods reinforces this isolation by filtering out, both consciously and unconsciously, and by the nature of synod membership, a lot of the common sense which keeps things going at parish level. As a result, the church at diocese level appears to many people to be an ivory Tower, the most removed part of which is the Lords spiritual.

Peter D Gardner's avatar

Nigel Biggar and Robert Tombs are correct as to the purpose of including Bishops in Parliament. But lately, the concept has been corrputed by wokery. Nevertheless, one must recognise that a great many Britons are woke, even believing that men can become women by choice.

J Butler's avatar

Many thanks Professor Biggar for your values - rather more substantive that the lists most of our politicians utter. I found them very though provoking bringing together a variety of loosely related but critical issues in one place. I thought that I should jot down a few brief comments but I began to enjoy myself and ended up with the essay below. On reflection I think the key point is encapsulated in your words:

"what has been won, can always be lost"

Unfortunately, I think many of these values have been lost and I can see no way of recapturing them.

Anyhow, my comments for what they are worth. The numbering refers to your values.

1. "Rule by the best" in the second chamber could be improved and freed from direct political interference by establishing the Lords as a revising chamber for "post holders". A post holder would be a person entitled to sit in the Lords whilst they held a designated position (usually the leadership) in a qualifying organisation; national institutions, learned bodies, the third sector, the judiciary, major corporates, religious orders etc. The initial post holder positions to be established by a Royal Commission with changes only being possible at regular fixed 10 years reviews and made by a successor Royal Commission.

2. Faith in government is also being undermined by the quality of our elected representatives. A minimum age and generous salary (with expenses being put on a basis similar to those of the directors of a PLC i.e. only expenses properly and fully incurred in relation to parliamentary business and subject to rigorous annual audit with full public disclosure) might help attract truly talented individuals with proven experience and success outside of politics. It is hard to put oneself up for public service, no matter how public spirited one may be, if the family has to endure a severe cut to their living standards.

3. The ECHR whilst problematic is a distraction from the real and much more serious endemic problems in our legal system. The increase in political activism of lawyers and the judiciary, the willingness of judges to interpret and thereby make new law beyond parliament’s legislative intent, judges’s willingness and ability to challenge democratically determined policy and the complete lack of any external judicial accountability, specifically democratic accountability.

The problem has largely arisen from Blair's constitutional reforms. The solution is to reverse those reforms; abolish the Supreme Court, re-establish the Law Lords in Parliament as the ultimate court of the land and restore to the Lord Chancellor his judicial oversight powers.

4. The concept of "equality under the law" was shredded by the misnamed equality legislations. This cumulated in the definition and establishment of “protected characteristics” and was, in essence, a long Orwellian journey to "All Animals Are Equal, But Some Are More Equal Than Others". Development of existing legislation with its generality applying to all individuals regardless of “identity” should have been sufficient to prevent and punish discrimination in all its forms. Pity poor Orwell, his books were a warning, they became a blueprint.

5. You have said this to any who are prepared to listen decide on the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth of the matter. But I see there is a new series on the BBC, “Finding Britain's Slave Traders with David Olusoga”. I wait in anticipation for Professor Olusoga, in accordance with the BBC’s principal of balance, to deliver a series “How Britain stopped the Global Slave Trade”. After all, it is “My BBC” and I am forced to pay my licence fee whether or not I choose to watch the BBC because of “the unique way that the BBC is funded”. I wish you every success in your byzantine struggle to hold the BBC to its charter commitments.

6. I would have add another point to do with equality around sexual orientation but perhaps it could be included here as a second but equally important sub point with women’s rights (should you want to keep the good symbolic 12 and avoid the bad symbolic 13). In general, being Homosexual is no more a threat to the rights of others (including women) than being Heterosexual. In contrast, the demands of “trans women” impinge directly on the rights of women and thus trans gender rights cannot be conflated with Gay and Lesbian rights (whatever the wavers of rainbow flags might think). Neither do I conflate cases of medically diagnosed severe gender dysphoria in adults where surgical intervention is a realistic possibility with men who want to retain their genitals but be treated as women and have access to women only spaces.

7. Although “no plat-forming” began in the 1960s, the chilling effect of “cancel culture” really started to be felt in the early 2000s in the university sector. The rapid expansion of student numbers under Blair required the recruitment of many more academics particularly in non STEMM subjects where expansion could be done cheaply and highly profitably. Standards predictably dropped but these academics needed to produce research to justify their existence and availability of original research materials was a naturally restricted supply in non STEMM subjects. The answer was of course to embrace postmodern deconstructionism where there were no truths, just my truth, your truth and their truth. This allowed for for the production of masses of “original” research papers that were effectively just a revision previous research with deconstruction applied. Importantly, this new research did not need any reference to newly discovered or indeed to any already known primary sources. It was simply a case of writing critiques of existing work through a kaleidoscope of different “lenses” and once that had been exhausted moving on to a synthesis of those critiques through the application of “intersectionality”. Whether this low grade academic environment gave rise to progressivism, was co-opted by progressivism or whether they grew symbiotically together is unclear. The results, however speak for themselves. We are now in the 2nd and approaching the 3rd generation of progressive teaching. Students who imbibed the creed at the turn of the century are now the teachers, tutors, lecturers and writers of course material for the next generation. They have captured many of our institutions so that progressivism is widely regarded as the norm, the natural and neutral state. Progressive educational materials in the widest possible sense are now enveloping our children from nursery school upwards leaving no room for questioning or a consideration of alternative points of view. Alarmingly, the rot is spreading rapidly into the sciences. Early and mid career scientists, scared for their careers and livelihoods, will not re-affirm biological truths. The Scientific Method and Empiricism are being roundly condemned as being colonialist and mechanisms of white oppression. “De-colonising the Mathematics Curriculum” has been an advertised event on the Oxford University official “events” webpage.

8. Most civil social bodies have been captured by progressivism. As such, through the use of weasel words and policies such as “do not share our values” or “would make some feel people unsafe” they explicitly or implicitly embrace cancel culture, prevent free association and the exchange of differing views and actively dampening down the liveliness of society. I can remember when comedians were funny rather than being partisan political bullies.

9. I won’t presume to tread on your lawn and I thank you for your interventions in the Church. However can I say that occasionally, just very occasionally, an elderly DD or similar will take the service at an Oxford college. How marvellous to hear prayers and sermons rooted in scripture rather than in the form of a progressive wish list. Why sometimes they even mention Christ outside of the BCP form of service.

10. How long for the UK? The constitutional vandalism of Blair (reinforced by Cameron) acts as a ratchet for separation, pushing ever wider, occasionally stalling but never going back. The nationalists have all the cards; if they don’t get what they want they blame Westminster and ferment dissatisfaction amongst their voters, get what they want and they hail it as their triumph attracting more voters and as a bonus increasing dissatisfaction amongst the English. We are also well into a form of apartheid. How many Scots now come south of the border for their university education, unless it is Oxbridge, when they can get it for free in Scotland? With the exception of St Andrews and to a lesser extent Edinburgh, how many English students will brave potentially hostile anglophobia in Scottish universities and towns only to find themselves economically 2nd class because they have to pay fees? But the sleeping monster is English Nationalism. At some point with repeated prodding from the governments of the devolved nations, the Kraken will wake. I love the UK more than I love England but I can see no future except separation.

11. Do you think this is still true? When will we have a plan to reach military spending of 3% of GDP by 2030? Do our allies still trust us? Can they rely on us? How many of our young people would be willing to fight? They are taught that we are a uniquely evil country. Without a shared history, culture, values or community who is the unjust aggressor and who is the innocent? Israel? Hamas? Iraq?

12. As discussed at various points above, gradual and prudent change ended with Blair. It is easy to explain why he did what he did, he has justified himself frequently. What remains inexplicable however, is that no significant Blair (or Brown) legislation was subsequently reversed by the Conservatives, not even when they had an outright majority.

Nicholas Dodd's avatar

This is a fine list of shared values, and, very importantly, stemming from our history. In my view, however, it's that very history that is the thing that binds us, and it's the loss of pride in that history that has made us so guilt-ridden and easily exploited. Even newcomers--whom we should get to choose of course--can buy into and be proud of that history, which is unique to us, and therefore particularly special. Oh, and we should not allow dual passports. You are either a citizen, with full rights and responsibilities, or merely a resident, who can't vote in national elections nor contribute to any decisions affecting the nation. Ok, I'm getting off topic. 🙂

Peter D Gardner's avatar

No 11 The Rule of The major-Generals, is interesting. It refers to the period when England and Wales were divided into ten regions, each governed by a major-general who answered to the Lord Protector (Cromwell).

A map of these regions bears an uncomfortable resemblance to the EU's map of 12 NUTS level 1 statistical territories of UK, including Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, and nine distinct regions of England. (NUTS= nomenclature d'unités territoriales statistiques. It would be French wouldn't it, like so many of the bad ideas from Europe?)

Cromwell wasn't a committee man but dictatorship is dictatorship whether it is a single person or EU or Soviet style dictatorship by committees of unelected supposed elites who claim to know better than we do what is best for us.

J Butler's avatar

John Reid's quote made me laugh. Self awareness? Not.

Peter D Gardner's avatar

I remember that during the debates around the EU referendum in 2016 most people had some difficulty defining 'British Values' and hence why Britain is distinct from Europe, not merely by geography, although geography has determined so much of the difference. It is always difficult to define national character even though so many jokes and humour rest on popularly recognised differences. Australia went through a debate about becoming a republic and again it was very difficult to mount a cultural argument for cutting Australia's ties with Britain.